Evsop of Kata Nikhoros(Teero in Afrek Etve)

jydeacon

Hey Guys I was wondering what your takes are on this issue, I noticed that in the HICS Recording of Afrek Etve they have shortened way of singing Afrek Etve in Teero while Ibrahim Ayad Sings Evsop(which corresponds to Teero) in a Melismatic way.  Here is Ibrahim's: http://tasbeha.org/media/index.php?st=Hymns/Major_Feasts_of_the_Lord/Resurrection/Ibrahim_Ayad/Part_3/11.Kata_Ni_Khoros.1139.mp3 

And Here is HICS: http://tasbeha.org/media/index.php?st=Hymns/Major_Feasts_of_the_Lord/Ascension/Higher_Institute_of_Coptic_Studies/05.Afrek_Etfe.1184.mp3

Is there a reason besides possibly a time factor in this where churches would say the abbreviated way or is it a school of teaching? How does Mlm Mikhael sing it? Or Mlm Fahim? Or even the majority of Cantors?

minatasgeel

[quote author=jydeacon link=topic=6665.msg89095#msg89095 date=1212371342]
Hey Guys I was wondering what your takes are on this issue, I noticed that in the HICS Recording of Afrek Etve they have shortened way of singing Afrek Etve in Teero while Ibrahim Ayad Sings Evsop(which corresponds to Teero) in a Melismatic way.  Here is Ibrahim's: http://tasbeha.org/media/index.php?st=Hymns/Major_Feasts_of_the_Lord/Resurrection/Ibrahim_Ayad/Part_3/11.Kata_Ni_Khoros.1139.mp3 

And Here is HICS: http://tasbeha.org/media/index.php?st=Hymns/Major_Feasts_of_the_Lord/Ascension/Higher_Institute_of_Coptic_Studies/05.Afrek_Etfe.1184.mp3

Is there a reason besides possibly a time factor in this where churches would say the abbreviated way or is it a school of teaching? How does Mlm Mikhael sing it? Or Mlm Fahim? Or even the majority of Cantors?


no. it's just the time factor. and of course, as always, Ibrahim Ayad is the Cathedral decon. the Cathedral always had this need of hymns for all the time that is being used in church, during services ya3ny. if am not mistakin, this part is also said/can be said, in apikran, maybe in another lahn, not sure......am losing my head today :D