Fr. Antonious Tanious- Palm Sunday Gregorian Liturgy

PopeKyrillos

Ok, so in the Gregorian Liturgy, first the Priest says Je Nai Nan then the congregation follows. Well I just saw this public video on facebook where Fr. Antonious's church says "Hosanna, King of Israel, Save us". Is this right?? I thought it was always "Have mercy upon us O God the Father, the pantocrator" on any occasion.

http://www.facebook.com/video/video.php?v=31609245603&oid=27507749656

PK

jydeacon

I'm not sure if this is part of the rite of Palm sunday but my priest does the same thing.

minatasgeel

[quote author=jydeacon link=topic=7094.msg94164#msg94164 date=1220573947]
I'm not sure if this is part of the rite of Palm sunday but my priest does the same thing.


i say that to. it's not as a rite it's a part that many priests used to do. the closest person i know who does that is Abouna David Bebawy in George's and before him Fr. Antonius Ragheb.

gergesezzat

Does any one has a source for that?

Amoussa01

I doubt it....i don't think its actually recorded as a rite. Some priests just do it because of the feast.

GB
Tony

minatasgeel

[quote author=Amoussa01 link=topic=7094.msg94341#msg94341 date=1221175825]
I doubt it....i don't think its actually recorded as a rite. Some priests just do it because of the feast.

GB
Tony


i have to agree with this to. same to [coptic]Je Nai nan[/coptic], with the Trinity included...not as the written source say that there are 2 versions....[coptic]`o Cwtyr nem piPantokratwr.[/coptic]

Amoussa01

Even though it is not a rite does not necessarily mean it is unacceptable, in my opinion. Prayer does not have to have a certain order for it to be considered prayer. However, i am not advocating people or priests to say whatever they want and get rid of the liturgies we have today - that would be a disaster. On the contrary; i just don't like how we can only accept prayer if it is written beforehand by someone else. Only in some cases, i do not find it to be a big deal.

Btw, the guy at the very end of the video (the deacon who is starring) is hilarious!

GB
Tony

minatasgeel

[quote author=Amoussa01 link=topic=7094.msg94346#msg94346 date=1221177596]
Btw, the guy at the very end of the video (the deacon who is starring) is hilarious!


am just shocked by how some of them are wearing black badrashels.

jydeacon

[quote author=minagir link=topic=7094.msg94347#msg94347 date=1221178456]
[quote author=Amoussa01 link=topic=7094.msg94346#msg94346 date=1221177596]
Btw, the guy at the very end of the video (the deacon who is starring) is hilarious!


am just shocked by how some of them are wearing black badrashels.


I actually don't think they are black, just REALLY dark red.

minatasgeel

[quote author=jydeacon link=topic=7094.msg94350#msg94350 date=1221179688]
[quote author=minagir link=topic=7094.msg94347#msg94347 date=1221178456]
[quote author=Amoussa01 link=topic=7094.msg94346#msg94346 date=1221177596]
Btw, the guy at the very end of the video (the deacon who is starring) is hilarious!


am just shocked by how some of them are wearing black badrashels.


I actually don't think they are black, just REALLY dark red.


not that DARK.....like i can see the other red ones...

Mark423

They're red. Made of a type of velvet that is very dark. But be assured they're red.

[Deleted User]

The user and all related content has been deleted.

nagyhm

does any one has a public link for this vedeo?

davidawad94

[quote author=PopeKyrillos link=topic=7094.msg94163#msg94163 date=1220571416]
Ok, so in the Gregorian Liturgy, first the Priest says Je Nai Nan then the congregation follows. Well I just saw this public video on facebook where Fr. Antonious's church says "Hosanna, King of Israel, Save us". Is this right?? I thought it was always "Have mercy upon us O God the Father, the pantocrator" on any occasion.



many priests do this on Palm Sunday. its normal. a priest in my church does it every palm sunday and I wait for it every year (Father Mikhail Tobia) and I heard many priests singing it.